Is milgram's study reliable
Witryna20 sty 2024 · As well as not taking humans and societies for granted. In doing so, I will refer to two studies that have generated various ethical issues. The first study was conducted in 1963 by Stanley Milgram on destructive obedience. The second study was conducted in 1976 by Middlemist, Knowles, and Matter on the effects of invasions on … WitrynaMilgram’s study (1963) was designed to test the ‘Germans are different’ hypothesis, to see if ordinary men would obey and order that would involve another human being hurt. Hofling’s study (1966) was also designed to test obedience, but used female nurses who were unaware that they were being experimented on as his subjects rather than men.
Is milgram's study reliable
Did you know?
Witryna13 lut 2024 · Reliability refers to the consistency of a measure and one aspect of reliability relevant to studies involving observations is how consistent different observers are when recording information on the same event i.e. inter-rater reliability. Witryna9 paź 2013 · Among the unpublished investigations, Perry discovered a remarkable condition that Milgram had kept secret. This was the study of ‘intimate relationships.’ Twenty pairs of people were recruited on the basis of a pre-existing intimacy. They were family members, fathers and sons, brothers-in-law, and good friends.
WitrynaThe Milgram experiment has been highly controversial, both for the ethics of its design and for the reliability of its results and conclusions. WitrynaObedience. Situational explanation. Hofling for support. Agentic state - no responsibility. Milgram study. Ethical & methodological issues. Define obedience. Form of SI - individual responds to direct order from another individual. Assumed that without this order, person wouldn't have acted this way.
Witryna14 lis 2024 · Milgram's work is also not truly replicable due to its ethical problems. However, the study has led to additional research on how situational factors can … Witryna1 maj 2015 · Objective This study investigates how obedience in a Milgram-like experiment is predicted by inter-individual differences.Methods Participants were 35 males and 31 females aged 26–54 from the...
WitrynaOne weakness of Milgram’s Experiment 13, which aimed to disentangle whether people obey orders due to the strength of the command itself or due to the status of the person giving the command, was whether the participants truly believed in the set up; if they did not, the validity of the results is arguably nil. Milgram himself says that it ...
WitrynaPDF On Jan 1, 2024, Nestar Russell and others published Are Milgram’s Obedience Studies Internally Valid? Critique and Counter-Critique Find, read and cite all the … bobble water bottle reviewsWitrynaStart studying Strengths and weaknesses of Milgram 1963 experiment. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. ... Indeed, the study was repeated using females and the same results were found (65% obeyed until the end) therefore it is reliable. bobble water bottle purpleWitryna4 kwi 2014 · Recent work on the reports of Milgram's volunteers suggested that there are no strong and reliable evidence that participants believed in the cover story 8, 14,18 . Others suggested that since the ... clinical labs of hawaii kona hospitalWitrynaMilgram’s study is a very controversial study as it broke many ethical guidelines and has many methodological issues, but it also had many strengths. One strength of the … clinical labs of hiloWitrynaAs a consequence, a reasonable doubt remains on how to interpret the results and this is one of the main critics associated with Milgram's studies and following versions. Recent work on the... bobble water bottle testWitryna2 mar 2015 · Indeed, in this regard, it is notable that Milgram himself saw his studies as a combination of science and art – arguing that film is unique in providing researchers … clinical labs online resultsWitrynaFirst, he concluded that this is a situation that produces extremely strong tendencies to obey. Second, he concluded that the situation generates extraordinary tension and emotional strain. Reliability The whole procedure was highly replicable, as was demonstrated by the fact Milgram was able to replicate it with 40 different participants. clinical labs of maui pukalani